Wednesday, 17 June 2026

A seriously flawed judgement: comparisons between Palestine Action and the Suffragettes by Lady Chief Justice Baroness Carr

 

 A seriously flawed judgement

Comparisons between Palestine Action and the suffragettes by Lady Chief Justice Baroness Carr 

 The rejection by Lady Chief Justice Baroness Carr of comparisons between Palestine Action and militant suffragettes are historical nonsense.  No one faced with the evidence could have said what Carr said that comparisons with groups such as the Suffragettes were 'seriously flawed'. 

For example take a look at the following information from Rebel Road on Emmeline Pankhurst https://markwrite.co.uk/2018/12/31/pankhurst-emmeline-and-her-daughters-christabel-and-sylvia-manchester/

The first WSPU meeting was held and the motto ‘Deeds not words’ was adopted. Those involved became known as The SUFFRAGETTES and they increasingly used militant tactics to raise awareness of their demands. Emmeline was arrested on many occasions. There were attacks on Churches after the Church of England  had voiced its opposition to the concept of suffrage. MPs’  windows were smashed and politicians were harassed and their meetings disrupted. Winston Churchill and Sir Edward Grey were assaulted when speaking in Manchester. 


                                  Emmeline Pankhurst statue in Manchester - copyright Mark Harvey 

Or Oldham’s Annie Kenney

https://markwrite.co.uk/2018/06/15/annie-kenney-oldham-2/

Kenney became involved in trade union activities but she is best known for her involvement in the Women’s Social and Political Union (WSPU). In October 1905, Kenney and Christabel Pankhurst interrupted a politician meeting to ask Winston Churchill and Sir Edward Grey about their views on whether women should be allowed to vote. 

When neither man replied and the women then got out a banner declaring ‘Votes for Women’ they were thrown out and arrested for obstruction. Kenney went to prison for 3 days. She was later involved in many other similar acts and suffered imprisonment on many occasions and during which time she was often force fed after participating in hunger strikes.  

Or Mary Gawthorpe of Leeds

https://markwrite.co.uk/2018/07/12/mary-gawthorpe-leeds/

 

Convicted for conspiracy to murder the Prime Minister and his cabinet minister 

There was also the fitting up of women fighting for the vote and, of which the best known is possibly Alice Wheeldon and her daughter and son-in-law. Following the decision by the Criminal Cases Review Commission in 2022 to reject an appeal for their convictions to be overturned all three remain convicted for conspiracy to murder Prime Minister Lloyd George and his cabinet minister Arthur Henderson in 1917.

https://markwrite.co.uk/2018/06/14/alice-wheeldon-1866-1895-peace-activist-socialist-and-suffragette/

In 2013 Derby City Council and Derby Civic Society erected a Blue Plaque as a memorial to Alice Wheeldon at her home on 29 Pear Tree Road, Derby. This was public recognition for the campaign, instigated by the Derby People’s History Group, to clear Wheeldon and her daughter and son-in-law, Winnie and Alf Mason, of their convictions for conspiracy to murder Prime Minister Lloyd George and his cabinet minister Arthur Henderson in 1917. Sentences of ten, five and seven years were imposed after a swift trial that gripped the nation.

An application for review to clear the name of the three people convicted of conspiring to kill the prime minister was rejected by the Criminal Cases Review Commission in 2022. Descendants continue to campaign for these convictions to be overturned.



https://alicewheeldon.org

Bradford’s Julia Varley too was sent to prison.



Read her story. https://markwrite.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/6328-julia-varley-booklet.pdf

In 2003 I published a book titled RADICAL AND REVOLTING – THE ENGLISH WORKING CLASS

One article by Carol Farmer was titled SUFFRAGE….A STRUGGLE FOR EQUAL RIGHTS. Read more below and the book can be read at:- https://markwrite.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/radicalandrevolting.pdf

 


 






No comments:

Post a Comment